CleenBeez Logo

CleenBeez

Back to Blog
Do You Still Need to Separate Colors in the Laundry? What Care Labels and Detergent Makers Say

Do You Still Need to Separate Colors in the Laundry? What Care Labels and Detergent Makers Say

By CleenBeez Team

Laundry

The care label decides. If it says "Wash with like colors" or "Wash separately," that item is not colorfast.

CleenBeez may earn a commission if you buy through links on this page. We pick products based on facts shown on brand labels, manufacturer pages, and product listings, not paid placement.

The short answer

The care label decides. If it says "Wash with like colors" or "Wash separately," that item is not colorfast. Under the FTC Care Labeling Rule, that warning has to be there when washing it the usual way would harm it or the clothes washed with it.

Wash new darks and brights alone for the first few washes. Tide says new and darkly colored items may bleed.

Bleach in the load? Sort. That is a load where sorting is not optional.

Wash towels apart for lint and abrasion, not dye.

No warning, no bleach, nothing new and dark? A mixed load is a reasonable call, but the detergent and washer makers below still say to keep new darks apart and keep whites away from colors.

Your clothes already tell you whether to sort. Read the tag before you split the pile.

What the care label rule actually says

The rule is 16 CFR Part 423. In the section on warnings for washing instructions, it says:

"If there is any part of the prescribed washing procedure which consumers can reasonably be expected to use that would harm the product or others being washed with it in one or more washings, the label must contain a warning to this effect. The warning must use words “Do not,” “No,” “Only,” or some other clear wording. [For example, if a shirt is not colorfast, its label should state “Wash with like colors” or “Wash separately.” If a pair of pants will be harmed by ironing, its label should state “Do not iron.”]"

The rule's glossary defines the two phrases:

  • "Separately": alone.
  • "With like colors": with colors of similar hue and intensity.

The FTC's business guide for the rule says the same thing in plainer words: "If a care procedure on one product could harm another product that is washed with it, the label must include a warning. For example, if an item is not colorfast, the label must say "Wash with like colors" or "Wash separately."" It also says a maker that uses "a dye that is known to bleed" may need test results to back up its care instructions.

Two limits worth knowing. First, the rule covers clothing (the FTC calls it "textile wearing apparel") and fabric sold to make clothing at home. Towels and bedding are not on the FTC's list of covered items, so do not expect the same label warning on them. Second, the rule tells you what the label must say. It does not promise that every unlabeled item will never fade.

Check the bleach line too

The same rule sets the bleach wording on care labels. In plain English:

  • No mention of bleach: all commercially available bleaches are fine for regular use.
  • "Only non-chlorine bleach, when needed": chlorine bleach would harm the item, but non-chlorine bleach would not.
  • "No bleach" or "Do not bleach": no bleach at all.

If you add bleach for whites, that is a load where sorting is not optional.

What detergent and washer makers say about sorting

  • Tide (P&G): "New items and darkly colored items may bleed, so wash them separately and turned inside out." It also says to "Wash deep colored clothing like indigo jeans or red sweatshirts by themselves for the first few washings," and that "Using cold water also helps minimize color transfer."
  • Blueland: "Cold water can help stop colors from bleeding. However, it is still not a good idea to wash whites and colors together in the washing machine. Even when using cold water and safe detergents for colors, there is always a chance that dye can transfer."
  • GE Appliances: "Separate white color items from dark color items and separate colorfast fabrics from non-colorfast fabrics."
  • Seventh Generation (directions on its Free & Clear detergent): "SORT: Follow garment care label instructions."

Not sure whether something is colorfast? Tide's test: apply warm water to a hidden spot, such as the inside of a hem, then press it with a warm iron between two pieces of cloth. "If any color leaks, it's not colorfast."

When sorting still matters

  • The label says so. "Wash with like colors" or "Wash separately" is the maker telling you the item is not colorfast.
  • New darks and brights. Tide says to wash them separately for the first few washes.
  • Bleach loads. Check the bleach line on each label and keep bleach away from colors.
  • Towels. This is about lint and abrasion, not dye. Tide says to wash heavier items like towels separately from lighter clothes "to prevent abrasion," and to keep lint shedders away from fabrics that attract lint. GE lists terry cloth as a lint producer.

When it matters less

If nothing in the load has a color warning, nothing is new and deeply dyed, and you are not using bleach, the rule gives you no reason to split the load. A cold wash is what Tide and Blueland point to for limiting color transfer.

So, is "modern dyes don't run" true? We can't call it true or false across the board. The care label is what tells you which items need sorting.

What to look for in the detergent

  • Cold-water directions: what the maker says about cold washes.
  • Scent wording: "fragrance-free" and "unscented" are different claims (see our fragrance-free vs unscented guide). We use each brand's own words.
  • Sorting direction from the maker: whether the brand tells you to follow the care label.
  • Format and loads per package.

For full detergent comparisons, see our best non-toxic laundry detergent for sensitive skin guide and how to choose a non-toxic laundry detergent without the greenwashing.

Comparison: four detergents for a mixed or colored load

Loads per package are as stated by each maker. Current prices are on each product page.

Product Format, loads Scent (brand wording) Cold water (maker) Sorting (maker)
Blueland Laundry Tablets Free & Clear Plastic-free tablets, 60 count (1 per load, 2 for large loads) "Free & Clear (a scent-free clean)" "formulated to clean clothes effectively in both hot and cold water" Do not mix whites and colors; "reference the garment's care instructions"
Seventh Generation Free & Clear Concentrated Laundry Detergent Liquid, 40 oz, 53 medium loads "made without fragrances, dyes, masking agents, or optical brighteners" Not stated in the directions we read "SORT: Follow garment care label instructions."
Meliora Plastic-Free Laundry Powder Unscented Powder, 35 oz, 128 HE loads "Unscented" "safe for all fabrics and water temperatures" Not stated
Molly's Suds Original Laundry Powder Unscented Powder, 47 oz, 70 loads "Unscented" Usable in cold, "but it performs better in warm and hot water" "read and follow laundry care labels"

For whites: Seventh Generation Oxy Booster Packs, Fragrance Free. Seventh Generation says the packs fight stains, "whitens whites, and is safe on colors," and are "made with 0% chlorine bleach." The maker says to use one pack per load for lightly soiled clothes and two for heavily soiled clothes.

Our pick

Blueland Laundry Tablets Free & Clear for cold-water colored loads, because its maker says it cleans in cold water and still tells you to keep whites and colors apart. Blueland describes it as "a scent-free clean," and its help page says to reference the garment's care instructions before washing.

See the Blueland Laundry Tablets Free & Clear pick

After the wash, our dryer sheets vs wool dryer balls guide covers the dryer step.

Bottom line

  1. Read the label. "Wash with like colors" or "Wash separately" means the item is not colorfast, and the FTC rule requires that warning when it applies.
  2. Wash new darks and brights alone for the first few washes (Tide).
  3. Keep whites and colors apart when bleach is in the load, and Blueland says to keep them apart anyway.
  4. Wash towels apart for lint and abrasion, not dye.
  5. No warning, no bleach, nothing new? A cold mixed load is a reasonable call.

Sources

Sign in to vote on this article

Looking for more healthy living tips?